|Mushrooms vs. Meat||09/20/17|
|Good news for GERD sufferers||09/14/17|
|Reseal the bag||09/06/17|
|Low-carb beats low-cal (except when it isn't)||08/30/17|
|The power of movie tie-ins||08/23/17|
|Diet sodas may still increase your risk of diabetes||08/16/17|
|Fight hunger - with chewing gum||08/09/17|
|Should you eat more frequently? Probably not||07/26/17|
|Drink coffee, live longer||07/19/17|
|Which fats are linked with diabetes risk?||07/12/17|
|Low fat diets may actually be bad for you||07/05/17|
|All Health and Nutrition Bites|
Drinking milk may be bad for your bones
For years, if not decades, we have been told to drink our milk in order to build strong bones. Milk is a good source of calcium, Vitamin D, and phosphorus, all important nutrients for bone formation and maintenance, so many people are told that they should drink at least three glasses a day to help prevent fractures and osteoporosis.
Dairy Products for Weight Loss
The dairy council would have you believe that eating more dairy products like milk, cheese and butter will help you lose weight. The research they point to, however, looked at people who were already on a low calorie diet who included three servings of dairy products in their diet. But if you're not reducing your calories and you eat more dairy, what happens? Do you lose weight anyway?
Dairy products, calcium, and fat intake
The National Dairy Council would have you believe that three servings of dairy products per day will help you lose weight. That's not quite true, as the original research followed people who had not previously been getting enough calcium going on a reduced-calorie diet that included the recommended three servings of low-fat dairy products in their diet plan. Other research, however, suggests that calcium intake might actually help people lose weight by causing the body to not absorb dietary fat.
Get the latest health and diet news - along with what you can do about it - sent to your Inbox once a week. Get Dr. Gourmet's Health and Nutrition Bites sent to you via email. Sign up now!
Although the dairy council no longer advertises that drinking milk or eating yogurt will help you lose weight, I still have the occasional patient who will ask me about it. Usually I tell them about the two studies I've reported on, first way back in 2006 and then another in 2009, that essentially concluded that dairy products by themselves would have no impact on weight: the gold standard for weight loss is still calories in versus calories out.
A meta-analysis (a study incorporating the data from multiple, smaller studies) published recently in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition revisits the question of weight and dairy products (2012;96(4):735-47). Nearly 30 different randomized controlled trials, including over 2,000 participants, were included in their study. The participants had to be over the age of 18 and the studies had to last for at least 4 weeks in order to be included in the meta-analysis. The different types of dairy used in the studies varied from low-fat milk to powdered milk to cheese and yogurt.
After standardizing the portions of dairy products across the multiple studies, the researchers were able to compare the outcomes of the studies with respect to weight loss and body fat in the case of either calorie-restricted diets or what is known as "habitual" diets (in which a participant follows their usual diet).
They found that those participants who ate dairy in studies that required them to reduce their caloric intake were more successful at weight loss than those who ate dairy and followed their usual diet. Similarly, those who ate dairy and reduced their caloric intake also lost significantly more body fat than those who ate dairy and followed their usual diet.
That said, when the researchers compared studies of shorter duration (less than 1 year) with longer studies (over 1 year), they saw that while body fat decreased in the shorter, calorie-restricted studies, for longer studies the amount of body fat actually increased.
Weight loss is not about short-term solutions, nor is it about dieting (in the sense of restricting calories). The most successful eating plan is one that you can sustain over the long term, and the results of this study show that increasing your dairy intake is unlikely to help you achieve long-term weight control. Don't worry about which foods are going to make your weight loss easier - focus on following a healthy diet for the long haul.
First posted: October 3, 2012